One of our family’s annual Christmas traditions is trying new Christmas cookie recipes, along with the old favorites, and then handing out small plates filled with goodies to our neighbors.
The kids love to help, and they are already planning on the types of cookies they want to make this year! As we have been going through options, we have compiled this giant list of Christmas cookies that we love, to share with you and your family!
Chocolate, Chocolate, Chocolate! Cookies!
This post contains affiliate links.
I mean, who doesn’t love chocolate, especially when it’s a part of a Christmas cookie recipe?! Here are a few recipes to satisfy the chocoholics in your life!
(Flourless) Fudgy Chocolate-Walnut Cookies, also from Food & Wine, are so good, that you’ll probably polish them off while transferring them from the cookie sheet to the platter! (Not speaking from experience, or anything…)
These Chocolate Chip Cookie (or Pie?) deep dish treats, from Chocolate Covered Katie, are delish!
You can’t go wrong with The Kitchen Is My Playground‘s gooey Turtle Cookies!
Life Love & Sugar‘s Double Mint Chocolate Chip Cookies are sure to be Santa’s favorite this year.
Quick and Easy Chocolate Cookie Recipes
Can you ever have enough chocolate cookie recipes? I’m going with, “nope.” So here are some more yummy choco-riffic Christmas cookie recipes.
My Nourished Home‘s Shortbread Cookies with Chocolate Ganache are to die for!
The Real Housemoms‘ Chocolate S’Mores Cookies are he best of both worlds–chocolate and toasted marshmallows!
I’m so excited to make a batch of My Nourished Home‘s Italian Biscotti Recipe! Perfect for dunking in coffee on Christmas morning!
Are you making tons of cookies for Christmas and running out of oven space? These No-Bake Mint Bars, from Real Housemoms, are tasty and do not need to be baked.
Add A New Spin to Traditional Christmas Cookie Recipes
You can treasure holiday classics while still making room for contemporary additions to your favorite Christmas cookie recipes!
If you’re a sucker for an ooey-gooey topping, like I am, you’ll have to try A Dash of Sanity‘s German Chocolate Cake Cookies!
Flour De Lis ties some of the best Christmas flavors together in one cookie, with these Chocolate Peanut Butter Caramel Cookies!
These Ganache-Dipped Chocolate Chip Cookies, from HGTV, are a fun twist on a classic!
Use leftover cookies or cake crumbs to make a yummy Cookie Butter!
Sure to WOW Christmas Cookie Recipes
Looking for a guaranteed way to please Santa and your holiday guests? These Christmas cookie recipes are sure to do the trick!
Gooey Chocolate Crinkle Cookies, from HGTV, look terrific on a Christmas Cookie platter, and they are easy to make!
The Nerd’s Wife‘s Christmas Swirl Sugar Cookies will look so pretty on your cookie platter!
Looking for a cute and functional centerpiece for Christmas dinner, or your dessert table? Try making a bouquet of Simplistically Living‘s Holiday Candy Cookie Pops!
Pineapple Upside Down S’mores are a lot of work to make, but 100% worth it, because delicious!
Cook Eat Delicious‘s Chocolate Pinwheels are SO pretty, and perfect for your holiday table!
Double Chocolate Chip Peppermint Cookies, from If You Give A Blonde A Kitchen, are very festive and yummy.
Simplistically Living‘s Candy Cane Crinkle Cookies are yummy and adorable!
Momofukufor2‘s Coconut Macaroons are one of our family’s Christmas staples!
Nut Butter Christmas Cookie Recipes:
Christmas just isn’t Christmas without peanut butter cookies! The good news about these Christmas cookie recipes is that if you have a peanut allergy, you can substitute the peanut butter with sunflower seed butter!
Chocolate Covered Katie‘s Inside Out Peanut Butter Cookies are so creamy they’ll melt in your mouth.
Here’s another one for peanut butter fans: Peanut Butter and Jelly Cookies, also from Buns In My Oven.
These No-Bake Chocolate Peanut Butter Bites, from Chocolate Covered Katie, are protein-packed cookies. Perfect for an after-school treat!
Combine your cookie with your latte with yummy Peanut Butter Chai Cookies, from Real Housemoms! I love how the spice adds a bit of zing to these cookies.
Peanut Butter Frosting, from Sprinkle Some Sunshine, is a totally unexpected way to bring your A-game to your peanut butter cookies this season, and beyond!
H0w adorable are The Nerd’s Wife‘s Penguin and Polar Bear Nutter Butter Cookies?! I can’t wait to try making them!
The Classic Christmas Cookie Recipe
These classic Christmas cookies are just as big a part of the big day as Santa and Rudolph! Many of these recipes bring back memories of snowy days, spent cozy in the kitchen with my mother and grandmother, making our family favorites, and trying out new Christmas cookie recipes!
Pip & Ebby‘s Pecan Cake Balls are quite literally amazeballs!
Christmas isn’t Christmas without Betty Crocker! Mint Thumb Prints are the perfect addition to Santa’s plate of cookies!
The Girl Who Ate Everything‘s Phat Cow Fudge is so good that you’ll wind up with soap in your mouth for yelling, “Ohhhh, fuuuuuudddddge!”
Landolakes‘ Light and Lovely Linzer Cookies are a traditional German Christmas cookie recipe that everyone will love!
Happy Hooligans‘ White Chocolate Chip Cranberry Cookies are the best winter cookie, and a fun way to switch up regular chocolate chip cookies if you’re getting sick of them!
This Macaron Recipe, from Giver’s Log, is an elegant way to dress up any holiday dessert table.
Mix and Match Christmas Cookie Recipes:
Gooey Joe-Joe’s Cookies and Cream Chocolate Bars, from Family Fresh Meals, mixes the best of the brownie and cookie worlds.
Family Fresh Meals‘ Oreo Stuffed Chocolate Chip Cookies are the best of both worlds. I can’t wait to dunk these in some milk!
Budding Baketress‘ Gingersnoodle is a perfect cookie mashable recipe–part gingerbread cookie, part snickerdoodle!
Simplistically Living‘s Grinch Crinkle Cookies are the greenest, meanest cookies around that also taste oh, so good!
What’s Cooking America‘s Chocolate Mint Wafer Cookies are a yummy way to make cutouts that pop!
No-Guilt Christmas Cookie Recipes:
You don’t have to miss out on yummy holiday snacks just because you’re watching your diet! With a little imagination, there are plenty of options for healthy Christmas cookie recipes!
Growing up, my great-grandmother regaled us with tales of her Christmas mornings as a child. In her stocking, she always found a tangerine or orange. Even as a child it struck me, how different my Christmas mornings were to hers, and it inspired me to savor simple pleasures… like these No-Bake Orange Cookies, from The Nerd’s Wife!
Healthy Apple Cookies are a healthy way to get your Christmas Cutout cookie fix, minus the guilt! Just use cookie cutter to shape slices of apple, and top them them with peanut butter, raisins, and nuts. Yum!
2-Ingredient No-Sugar Cookies are a great breakfast option!
My Nourished Home‘s Healthy Oatmeal Breakfast Cookies are another yummy and healthy option for Christmas morning.
I can’t think of a better way to start my morning, than with Mavis Butterfield’s 100 Dollars A Month‘s Chocolate Chip Cookies With Almonds, Cranberries, and Coconut! So yummy with a cup of coffee!
Gluten-Free (and Some Nut-Free and Sugar-Free) Christmas Cookie Recipes:
Food allergies don’t have to come between you and your favorite holiday sweets! You just have to get creative and substitute certain ingredients in your Christmas cookie recipes! Here are some delicious gluten-free cookie recipes to get you started. Some of these are nut-free cookie recipes, and sugar-free cookie recipes, too!)
Does one of your family members have a peanut allergy? If so, these Christmas Kiss Blossoms (without peanut butter) from Welcome to the Family Table® are a wonderful substitute!
These Chocolate Amaretti Cookies, from Food & Wine, are tasty AND gluten-free!
Fruit Pizza-by-the-Slice, from fashionedible.com, has wonderful plate presentation. I just love all the colors! Plus it’s healthier and gluten-free!
Don’t knock Bean Cookies and Beet Icing from Super Healthy Kids until you try them! These cookies taste yummy, are all-natural, and dye-free (perfect for your guests with food-dye allergies). They are also good for you!
No-Bake Cashew Cookies, from Super Healthy Kids, are a great healthy alternative for families who have sugar-free and gluten-free diets.
Chocolate Covered Katie‘s Hot Fudge Larabars technically aren’t cookies, but they taste as just good, and they’re better for you!
Chia Power Balls, from The Honour System, are a sweet treat that perfectly transcends from Christmas Eve to New Year’s Day! These are great on the go, and so healthy!
After-School Christmas Cookie Recipes
These Christmas cookie recipes are a fun after-school snack/ lunchbox surprise for your little ones all month long, as they eagerly await Santa’s visit!
Sweetened with Molasses, Super Healthy Kids‘ Whole Grain Ginger Cookies are the best whole grain soft ginger cookie out there.
Classic Christmas Cookie Recipes Never Go Out Of Style!
Along with the occasional designer bag or shoes, you would be smart to invest in some of these classic Christmas cookie recipes. They will always be on-trend on Christmas morning! These are the best Christmas cookie recipes for a Christmas cookie swap or exchange!
Hostess With the Mostess has a recipe for White Chocolate Cherry Shortbread Cookies that is delicious, served with tea!
Lemonade Cookies are a fun twist on the Christmas Classic, lemon bars. They keep help keep summer alive during the holidays!
Unicorn Poop Cookies are perfect for any Christmas cookie platter, because Rudolph is so magical that he has to have a unicorn cousin somewhere!
Jornie.com‘s Giant Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookies are the best, because we’ve all taken a bite out of what we thought was an oatmeal chocolate chip cookie, but it was really oatmeal raisin. Been there. Done that. These are better!
Funfetti Cookies, from Your Modern Family, are the best cookie to make for the school holiday party! Just about every kid loves frosting, and you can tailor the frosting and sprinkle colors to go along with any holiday. Plus, there are only three ingredients needed, so these are quick and easy to make when you’re in a hurry!
Italian Anisette Cookies, from Amanda’s Cookin‘, are one of those Christmas cookies that takes me straight back to my childhood Christmases! For those of you who aren’t huge fans of anise, this recipe has an almond variation.
Are They From A Bakery, Or Did You Make Those Amazing Christmas Cookies?
These recipes are so good that your family and friends will secretly be wondering if you transferred the cookies from a bakery box onto one of your own plates right before the party!
Red Velvet Crinkle Cookies, from Foodie Fun, are easy to make, and they look stunning!
Eat Well 101‘s Chocolate Cookies look like they have been dusted with fresh snow!
My grandmother has made these Chocolate-Chip-And-Pecan Bars, from delish.com, for family gatherings as far back as I can remember. They are SO GOOD!
More Christmas Treat and Cookie Recipes
What is your favorite Christmas cookies recipes? Please hop over to our FB page and share!